Most apples will grow in Scotland, but the RHS describes six of its recommended varieties as "suitable for northerly, colder, higher rainfall areas". That's the shortlist to start from. After that, the choice comes down to pollination, when the fruit ripens and how long it keeps.

Quick answer

James Grieve, if you have room for two trees. Scrumptious if you only have room for one. Edward VII for cooking apples that keep until April, and Grenadier for an early cooker.

What Scotland means for the choice

The six are James Grieve, Egremont Russet, Emneth Early, Grenadier, Lord Lambourne and Edward VII. Hardiness doesn't separate them from other apples: all are rated H6The RHS's H1a–H7 scale for how much cold a plant can survive outdoors, H1a being tender indoor-only and H7 hardy anywhere in the UK. Full definition →, hardy anywhere in the UK. What matters more is a late frost at blossom time, which can cost a season's crop. A sheltered site out of a frost pocketA low-lying spot where cold air drains and pools on still nights, making it noticeably more frost-prone than the surrounding area. Full definition → helps any variety; check your area's frost dates. The apple growing guide covers rootstocksThe root system and lower stem a fruit tree is grafted onto, chosen to control the tree's eventual size rather than for its own fruit. Full definition →, planting, pollination groups and pruning.

A smaller red-flushed dessert apple next to a larger pale green culinary apple
James Grieve (left), an early dessert apple, and Edward VII (right), a late cooker that keeps until April.
VarietyUseSeason of usePollination groupA classification of fruit tree varieties by when they flower each spring, used to check whether two varieties can pollinate each other. Full definition →Notes
James GrieveDessert, or cooking if picked earlySeptember to October3Good, regular crops; bruises easily
Egremont RussetDessertOctober to December2Partly self-fertileA plant that can set fruit using its own pollen, without needing a second, different variety nearby to cross-pollinate it. Full definition →
Lord LambourneDessertLate September to November2Good flavour, moderate vigour
Emneth EarlyCookingAugust to September3Heavy crops, often every other year; thin the fruit
GrenadierCookingAugust to September3Reliable early cooker
Edward VIICookingDecember to April6Flowers very late, so escapes frosts

All six hold the RHS Award of Garden Merit (AGMThe RHS's Award of Garden Merit: a UK-wide trials award for reliable performance, not a Scotland-specific recommendation. Full definition →), a UK-wide award rather than a Scottish one. The "northerly, colder" description is the part that speaks to Scottish conditions.

James Grieve

James Grieve was raised in Scotland at the end of the 19th century and is still the pick for most gardens. It gives good, regular crops of yellow-green apples striped orange-red, with juicy, crisp-to-melting flesh, and can be picked early for cooking. It's in pollination group 3, so it pairs easily with Scrumptious, Grenadier or Emneth Early, or with the group 2 varieties. The one drawback: it bruises easily, so eat it rather than store it.

Edward VII, for frost and storing

Edward VII is a cooker with good, regular crops of large apples that cook to a well-flavoured purée, less sharp than Bramley. It "flowers very late so escapes frosts", which suits a Scottish garden, and it keeps from December to April. The catch is pollination: none of the others here flowers as late, so it needs a late-flowering partner from outside this list. A crab apple, which flowers over a long period, can do the job.

The other four

Egremont Russet is a russet dessert apple for October to December, partly self-fertile. Lord Lambourne is a well-flavoured dessert apple of moderate vigour, late September to November. Grenadier is a reliable early cooker for August and September. Emneth Early is another early cooker that gives heavy crops, typically every other year, so thin the fruit; see biennial bearing.

One tree only: Scrumptious

Most apples need a second variety flowering at the same time nearby. Scrumptious is self-fertile, so it fruits on its own, with red apples that have a complex, honeyed flavour in September and October. It isn't one of the six described as suited to northerly areas, but it's the answer where there's room for just one tree.

Triploids need two partners

Bramley's Seedling, Ribston Pippin and Warner's King are triploids: they need pollinating but can't pollinate anything else, so each needs two other compatible varieties nearby. Unless you have room for three trees, leave them out.

Which one for your situation

  • Two trees, eating apples: James Grieve with Egremont Russet or Lord Lambourne.
  • One tree: Scrumptious.
  • A frost-prone garden: Edward VII, with a late-flowering partner.
  • Apples to store into spring: Edward VII.
  • An early cooker: Grenadier or Emneth Early.

None of these resists scab, powdery mildew or canker, which favour wet weather and heavy soil, so manage them whichever you grow. Codling moth and woolly aphid don't pick favourites either.

Common questions

Do I need two apple trees?

Usually, yes: most apples need a second variety flowering at the same time. Scrumptious is self-fertile and fruits alone. Triploids such as Bramley's Seedling need two partners.

Which apple copes best with late frosts?

Edward VII, which flowers very late and so escapes frosts. It needs a late-flowering partner, such as a crab apple.

Does an AGM mean an apple suits Scotland?

Not on its own: the AGM is a UK-wide award. Six AGM apples also carry the RHS note "suitable for northerly, colder, higher rainfall areas": James Grieve, Egremont Russet, Emneth Early, Grenadier, Lord Lambourne and Edward VII.

Sources

Show the 13 sources